Emergency Banner

Plaintiff’s Strategy Backfires, Resulting in Victory for Defendant

Martin Blaya, of our Miami office, with the assistance of KD’s Appellate and Coverage Practice Group, convinced a court to enforce a settlement previously entered into by the plaintiff. The plaintiff argued that the settlement was invalid for two reasons: (1) she had not yet been named the personal representative of her father’s estate when the settlement was entered into in her name on behalf of her father’s estate; and (2) she did not authorize her prior attorney to enter into the settlement agreement and, therefore, the prior attorney had no authority to settle the claim. Importantly, regarding this second argument, the plaintiff invoked attorney-client privilege during her deposition, with the court sustaining those objections, making it impossible to discover what exactly the plaintiff may or may not have authorized her prior attorney to do with respect to settling the claim. Fortunately, the plaintiff’s prior attorney was not so tight-lipped, and he testified that he had the plaintiff’s express authority to settle the claim. At the hearing on the motion to enforce settlement, Martin argued that, under Florida law, the powers of a personal representative relate back in time to validate acts made by the person prior to being officially appointed. And sealing the fate of the plaintiff, Martin lastly argued that because the plaintiff invoked her attorney-client privilege—preventing the discovery of information that went to the heart of this dispute—the court was left to rely solely on the testimony of the plaintiff’s prior attorney, which supported the defendant’s position. The court agreed and granted the defendant’s motion to enforce settlement.

Share Now:

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Recent Posts

Jury Returns Verdict Well Below Plaintiff's Damages Request in Auto Accident Case
Jason Friedman, of our Fort Lauderdale office, and Jared Brownfield, of our Tallahassee office, secured a favorable jury verdict in a motor vehicle accident...
A Warm Welcome to Our 2026 Summer Law Clerks
We’re excited to welcome our 2026 Summer Law Clerks to several of our Florida offices. This summer, they’ll gain hands-on experience, build meaningful...
KD Proudly Supports Mental Health Awareness Month
As Mental Health Awareness Month comes to a close, KD is proud to have stood together in support of mental wellness — in the workplace and beyond. By wearing...

Only PDF, JPG or GIF can be uploaded.

Search Results Will Show Here

Subscribe To Our Newsletter