Emergency Banner

Fifth DCA Reversal of Order Granting New Trial Following Defense Verdict in Slip and Fall at an Amusement Park

Angela  Flowers, of the Ocala office, recently obtained a reversal of the trial court’s order granting Plaintiff a new trial based on allegedly improper—but unobjected to—defense closing arguments of outside trial counsel. This case arose from a slip-and-fall at an amusement park where the jury returned a complete defense verdict. That victory was initially wiped out by the trial court’s order granting a new trial. As Angela explained in her briefs in the appeal, one thing that made this case unusual is that, within 3 days after the fall, Plaintiff began treating with a chronic pain management specialist even before seeing his primary doctor, and each of his treating physicians acquired an immediate, direct financial interest in the litigation. At trial, Plaintiff’s counsel made a tactical decision to preemptively explain and elicit that he referred Plaintiff to the pain doctor, and, in closing argument, he offered what amounted to unsworn explanations for his referral relationship with the treating doctors. The trial court deemed comments made by defense counsel in closing arguments on the subject to be fundamental error. On appeal, Angela persuaded the appellate court to reverse and reinstate the defense verdict. Although the appellate court found that certain defense arguments were improper, the court was persuaded that the unobjected-to comments did not rise to the level of fundamental error. Specifically, had Plaintiff objected to the closing arguments, they could have been cured by a timely objection, after which the trial court could have issued a curative instruction to the jury. Accordingly, the court reversed and remanded to reinstate the jury’s defense verdict.

Share Now:

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Recent Posts

Business Interruption Coverage in COVID-19 Pandemic Requires “Direct Physical Loss”
In Fontainebleau Fla. Hotel, LLC v. Westchester Surplus Lines Ins. Co., No. 3D23-1264 (Fla. 3d DCA Mar. 19, 2025), the Third District held that business...
KD at the Construction Law Institute 2025
Bryan Krasinski and Jessica Prats from our Tampa office, along with Leeza Newman from our West Palm Beach office and Michelle Krone from our Ft. Myers...
Palm Beach County Bar Association - Bench Bar Conference 2025
KD team member Mark Young, from our West Palm Beach office, participated in the annual Bench Bar Conference hosted by the Palm Beach County Bar Association. Mark...

Search Results Will Show Here

Subscribe To Our Newsletter