Emergency Banner

Favorable Result at Trial in Premises Liability Case

Harold A. Saul of the Tampa office, obtained a favorable result at trial in a premises liability case. An employee of the property owner asked the Plaintiff, who was both a friend and an air conditioning technician, to take a look at a leaky air conditioner on the roof. While using a ladder that the employee had placed against the building earlier in the day, Plaintiff fell and suffered a collapsed lung, ruptured spleen, 7 broken ribs and an alleged disc herniation in his neck resulting in over $120,000 in medical bills and a 5-day hospital stay. The Plaintiff claimed the employee was holding the ladder at the time he fell, but the employee testified he was entering the office at the time and was not holding the ladder. Plaintiff made a significant demand and refused to negotiate. At trial, Harold argued the Plaintiff was the sole cause of the accident and disputed the amount of damages claimed. After a three-day trial, the jury found the employee 50% negligent and Plaintiff 50% negligent. After reduction for Plaintiff’s comparative fault and collateral source setoffs, the jury’s net verdict for the Plaintiff was substantially less than the last settlement offer made by Harold.

Share Now:

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Recent Posts

KD's First Party Practice Group Presents: The Florida Prejudice Playbook
When is notice “too late,” and when does late notice actually prejudice the carrier? This three-part series walks through Florida’s two-step prejudice...
Congratulations to our newest Equity Partners!
Congratulations to our newest Equity Partners! Your commitment and leadership have helped shape who we are today. We’re proud to celebrate this well-earned...
Tampa Team Secures Defense Verdict in PIP Declaratory Judgment Action
Teodora Siderova and Sean Becker of our Tampa office successfully defended an insurance carrier in a declaratory judgment action filed by an insured seeking...

Only PDF, JPG or GIF can be uploaded.

Search Results Will Show Here

Subscribe To Our Newsletter