Emergency Banner

Complete Defense Verdict in Property Damage Case Where Plaintiff Unsuccessfully Tried to Bring Lost Wages and Mental Anguish Claims

Kimberly A. Beckwith, of our Tampa office, obtained a defense verdict in a case for property damage, lost wages, and mental anguish. The client drove off the road and crashed through Plaintiff’s fence, garden, truck, and landed squarely in the middle of Plaintiff’s mobile home. Luckily, no one was hurt, but our client was arrested for DUI. Plaintiff sued Defendant in small claims court claiming property damage, mental anguish, and lost wages. Kim filed a motion to dismiss outlining the numerous deficiencies with Plaintiff’s claims, including that 1) since he was not injured, his claim for mental anguish is barred, and 2) his claim for 6 weeks of lost wages was without support. Kim persuasively argued that Plaintiff voluntarily took off from work to repair some of the damage, that a hand-written letter from his employer regarding Plaintiff’s pay rate was inadequate to establish damages. At trial, Plaintiff attempted to add to his damages by claiming additional losses of personal property to which Kim quickly shot down by pointing out that he previously signed a property damage release. The Judge gently explained to Plaintiff that his case was flawed and ruled in favor of our client, entering a complete defense verdict.

Share Now:

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Recent Posts

Webinar Debrief - What Changed? Key Legal Developments in Florida’s Late Notice & Prejudice Law
In case you missed our recent webinar on Florida Prejudice in Late-Reported Property Claims, here are the key takeaways for Florida adjusters: Florida...
Paola Solano Galindez Earns Prestigious 40 Under 40 Recognition
We’re proud to share that Paola Solano Galindez, of our Miami office, has been selected for inclusion in the Miami-Dade Bar Association Young Lawyers Section’s...
Complete Defense Verdict in Lee County Rear-End Trial
Stefanie Capps and Emily Huang, of our Ft. Myers office, obtained a complete defense verdict in Lee County in a rear-end accident case with admitted liability. Although...

Only PDF, JPG or GIF can be uploaded.

Search Results Will Show Here

Subscribe To Our Newsletter